Monday, November 19, 2007

Q 20

Some of the subtleties of Anne’s character might not be explicitly stated. Other aspects of her character might be implied through comparison with other characters in the novel. The same goes for other characters in the novel as well. In the following description of the Musgroves, what character traits are attributed to being “modern”? What does imply about Anne’s own relationship to the changing times? How does this give us some insight into Anne’s thinking?

“The Musgroves, like their houses, were in a state of alteration, perhaps of improvement. The father and mother were in the old English style, and the young people in the new. Mr. and Mrs. Musgrove were a very good sort of people; friendly and hospitable, not much educated, and not at all elegant. Their children had more modern minds and manners. There was a numerous family; but the only two grown up, excepting Charles, were Henrietta and Louisa, young ladies of nineteen and twenty, who had brought from school at Exeter all the usual stock of accomplishments, and were now, like thousands of other young ladies, living to be fashionable, happy, and merry.” (77-78)

5 comments:

tami said...

The character traits that are attributed to being "modern" in this passage have to do with being "accomplished" and educated and headstrong. In the beginning we are given a comparison between Mr. And Mrs. Musgrove who are "old english style" not being educated and not at all elegant. Their children on the other hand are "in the new" with more "modern minds" and being well mannered. It seems to also attribute traits like being fashionable,happy,and enjoying life to its fullest potential to be "modern traits". This passage seems to point out that Anne is envious of this lifestyle that is not only upbeat and lively but adventurous and fun-loving, but somewhat afraid to say so. We are once again given a contrast between the life Anne is living and the life the Musgrove girls are living. Anne is living a life that doesn't go along with the girls that are described as "modern" and ambitious. She is practical and doesn't necessarily follow her desires and pleases others instead of herself.It says in the passage that the Musgroves are " in a state of alteration, perhaps of improvement". which implies that change from old to new is something positive and seen as something that can "improve" life which makes us believe that Anne isn't against this change. It not only shows us that she envies this lifestyle but that she is a very practical girl and makes it seem as though this lifestyle isn't something that she would trade for her own.

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Erin Trapp said...

this is one of the more interesting comparisons... anne is able to look on agreeably but wihtout envy... how is this affirmed when wentworth comments on louisa? is the musgrove's "perhaps" improvement a comment on the greater society?

Anonymous said...

Anne is definitely has a "modern" character, one that is associated with being ahead of her time. Her thinking is not like most women of the time. Austen makes Anne seem feminine, but she has none of the negative qualities of the "typical" woman. Instead, she is headstrong, considerate, and level headed. She also rebels against the vain and superficial qualities of her father and sisters, and takes a more "modern" view on society and life.

cindy said...

Modern seems to mean educated, cultured, and concerned with the pursuits of a happy. comfortable life. Anne seems to embody some of the less frivolous of these attributes, with her love of books, poetry, and intelligent conversation. Though she seems to admire the ability of the Musgrove girls in their pursuit of the finer things in life, she isn't disposed to join in and can rarely be persuaded to. This is reflected in one of her musings, I forgot where, when she comments on how people often admire the lifestyles of others while not exactly wanting it for themselves.